The Cycle of “Passing the Buck”
Have you ever worked for a manager who refused to make a decision? Information goes up, but a clear course of action never comes back down. Instead, the issue is endlessly pushed up the chain of command, paralyzing teams and breeding frustration. This cycle of “passing the buck” is one of the most common complaints in the modern Indian workplace.
But what if this isn’t just a case of bad management?
What if it’s the result of deep-seated cultural patterns we learned as children?
This article explores the surprising takeaways from a classic 1975 study by Gouranga P Chattopadhyay that uncovers the cultural roots of dependence in Indian society and its profound impact on professional life. These insights reveal four “hidden scripts” that dictate behavior in the workplace. Decades after they were first identified, they remain as relevant as ever in explaining why so many organizations struggle with accountability, risk-taking, and genuine collaboration.
1. The Top-Down Problem: Why Leaders Model the Wrong Behavior
The first script is set at the very top. Senior leaders often abdicate their own responsibility to learn and be vulnerable, which sets a powerful—and negative—example for the entire organization.
In his study, Chattopadhyay details a corporate workshop designed to fix this very problem of “abdication of responsibility.” The consultant who was hired had a working hypothesis: either senior managers weren’t delegating authority, or they were abdicating their own responsibilities and the juniors were simply modeling their behavior.
The workshop confirmed the latter. The chief executive and his general managers agreed to attend but announced at the outset that they would be “observers,” not participants. This single action sent two clear messages to the junior managers present:
Seniors are above learning with their subordinates and must not expose their weaknesses.Seniors are not accountable and can break commitments with impunity.
The charade continued. On the second day, the chief executive “bravely joined one of the groups, but kept silent right through, twice went out to receive phone calls and, at the end of the day, paid great tributes to the consultant!” He maintained his observer role while trying to “placate” the consultant with compliments.
This behavior directly creates a system where junior managers learn not to take risks or make independent decisions. Why would they, when their leaders have shown that the safest path is to avoid accountability? They instead push information upwards until it hits the top, paralyzing the decision-making process and creating a culture of dependency.
As the study reflects on the outcome of the leaders’ behavior: “By thus not participating, they presented a model — which, in any case, the enterprise was following: Abdicate your responsibility so long as you can avoid being accountable for it”
2. The Family Blueprint: How We’re Taught to Depend
This top-down abdication in the corporate world is not a learned behavior unique to the office; it is a direct reflection of a script written in the home. The traditional Indian family structure, with its emphasis on an all-powerful, non-accountable father figure, serves as the primary “breeding ground” for a culture of dependence.
Planning a leadership offsite or culture reset?
Download the free Leadership Offsite Design Guide: six steps to leave the room aligned on what changes.
Chattopadhyay describes a child-rearing process with a clear, unwritten rule: success is attributed to following the father’s advice, while failure is always blamed on the son’s “waywardness.” The father is never held accountable for the outcome of his guidance. This system is based on punishment for deviation rather than reward for being oneself. A child learns that their value lies not in their intrinsic worth, but in their ability to imitate authority and follow orders.
This upbringing produces two distinct adult archetypes in the workplace. The first grows up with a “poor self-image,” believing his worth lies in imitating authority; he becomes a manager who expects and enforces unquestioning obedience. The second becomes the “‘confident type” who is secretly “tense, ready to burst into a fit of anger” and becomes a highly critical boss who values punishment.
This script is passed on through powerful psychological loops. The study describes how a son, after being forced into a marriage or career, rationalizes his unhappiness by telling himself it was his “holy duty to comply” with his parents’ wishes. This logic then makes it natural for him to expect the same unquestioning obedience from his own children, perpetuating the cycle.
“It is because of the image of the all-powerful father and the dependent son — a dependent son whose success is attributed to properly executing his father’s advice while his failures are blamed on his waywardness or on ill-luck.”
3. The Paradox of “Participation”: Consulting Without Empowering
The third script reveals a major contradiction in Indian management culture: managers often profess a belief in “group-based, participative decision-making” but actually practice an autocratic style.
The study clarifies that “participation” is frequently redefined to fit this dependent culture. It becomes what the source calls a “make-believe process of participative decision-making.” In practice, it looks like a leader sitting with subordinates, informing them of a decision that has already been made, and expecting their acceptance. It’s a performance of consultation, not a genuine collaboration.
A supporting analysis from a study by Tandon reinforces this point, noting that this practice is rooted in family dynamics where the goal is harmony, not shared authority.
“Indian managers like to be kept in touch and consulted more than their Western counterparts. I think this arises from diffused authority in the joint family… Similarly, the Indian managers feel they ought to be in on things and not kept out… delegation works better than it does in India, because authority and responsibility are clearly defined and not bedevilled by constant consultation merely to keep people happy”.
This approach is counter-productive. It creates an illusion of teamwork while reinforcing the underlying dependence culture. By engaging in consultation “merely to keep people happy,” leaders prevent junior employees from ever learning true ownership, critical thinking, and the skills needed to make decisions for themselves.
4. The Aggression Vacuum: From Coddled Babies to Chaotic Adults
The final script originates in infancy, creating an “aggression vacuum” where adults lack a healthy middle ground for managing frustration. A key aspect of Indian child-rearing—not allowing infants to experience frustration—leads to adults who cannot manage aggression in a controlled, constructive way.
Chattopadhyay cites a study by Wiser and Wiser, which observed that Indian infants are never allowed to cry for long; they are “immediately picked up and cuddled.” This is contrasted with Western children, who are often allowed to cry. As a result, they “learn to handle anger and frustration and channel their energy to find ways to entertain themselves, even if it is as simple an act as chewing the bed-cloth!” The study includes a vivid example of this conditioning:
“…a three-year-old who spends much time in our grove riding thus on mother’s hip, When we persuade him to try walking, he takes a few stroddling steps, then sits down and howls. The mother beams with pride at her importance to him, and lifts him back to her hip…”
The consequence of this upbringing is an adult who oscillates between two extremes. Faced with a frustrating situation, they either stoically accept it or, as the study notes, “burst out in a frenzy that creates chaos,” citing the example of student protests that turn destructive. What is missing is the capacity for sustained, organized, and constructive action to solve problems. In the workplace, this hinders their ability to challenge the status quo, drive innovation, or engage in the healthy conflict that is necessary for progress.
Seeing the Script
These four points reveal a powerful, interconnected system. Workplace behaviors like avoiding responsibility, engaging in “fake” participation, and an inability to challenge authority are not isolated flaws. They are symptoms of a deeply ingrained cultural system of dependence that begins in childhood and is reinforced by family structures, educational systems, and corporate hierarchies.
These scripts run in the background of our professional lives, quietly shaping our actions and limiting our potential. Recognizing them is the first step, but the real challenge lies ahead: How can individuals and organizations begin the difficult work of rewriting them?




